One of my harddisks in BTRFS multi-disk backup array died. I didn't know, until I rebooted after system update. Fortunately, I had enough space to cover this failure. But, if another harddisk dies, then I will need to buy a new one. What is your recommendation for NAS harddisk, nowadays? It's been awhile since I shopped for a harddisk. Google recommends Seagate Ironwolf Pro, but I got burned by Seagate before, and this one that died is also Seagate.
Personally I like Seagate but I have other as well. But I use only STD drive they are so much faster. Tom On Saturday, September 19th, 2026 at 11:14 PM, William Park via Talk <talk@lists.gtalug.org> wrote:
One of my harddisks in BTRFS multi-disk backup array died. I didn't know, until I rebooted after system update. Fortunately, I had enough space to cover this failure. But, if another harddisk dies, then I will need to buy a new one.
What is your recommendation for NAS harddisk, nowadays? It's been awhile since I shopped for a harddisk. Google recommends Seagate Ironwolf Pro, but I got burned by Seagate before, and this one that died is also Seagate.
------------------------------------ Description: GTALUG Talk Unsubscribe via Talk-unsubscribe@lists.gtalug.org Start a new thread: talk@lists.gtalug.org This message archived at https://lists.gtalug.org/archives/list/talk@lists.gtalug.org/message/KRBAQOI...
On 2026-09-19 23:13, William Park via Talk wrote:
One of my harddisks in BTRFS multi-disk backup array died. I didn't know, until I rebooted after system update. Fortunately, I had enough space to cover this failure. But, if another harddisk dies, then I will need to buy a new one.
What is your recommendation for NAS harddisk, nowadays? It's been awhile since I shopped for a harddisk. Google recommends Seagate Ironwolf Pro, but I got burned by Seagate before, and this one that died is also Seagate.
I personally have had good luck with segate over the years but if you checkout Backblaze you can get an idea of bulk drive reliability. Backblaze seems to like to generate quarterly reports on drive reliability. https://www.Backblaze.com/blog/Backblaze-drive-stats-for-q1-2026/ Their data is not presented in a way that presents the most->least reliable drives but from their stats it looks like segate is not the best. -- Alvin Starr || land: (647)478-6285 Netvel Inc. || home: (905)513-7688 alvin@netvel.net ||
On Sat, Sep 19, 2026 at 11:13:16PM -0400, William Park via Talk wrote:
One of my harddisks in BTRFS multi-disk backup array died. I didn't know, until I rebooted after system update. Fortunately, I had enough space to cover this failure. But, if another harddisk dies, then I will need to buy a new one.
What is your recommendation for NAS harddisk, nowadays? It's been awhile since I shopped for a harddisk. Google recommends Seagate Ironwolf Pro, but I got burned by Seagate before, and this one that died is also Seagate.
I saw an article recently that showed Seagate drives failed twice as often as WD drives. So it turns out it was not our imagination that Seagate drives were less reliable. I run WD Red Plus drives. -- Len Sorensen
On 2026-09-22 11:08, Lennart Sorensen via Talk wrote:
On Sat, Sep 19, 2026 at 11:13:16PM -0400, William Park via Talk wrote:
One of my harddisks in BTRFS multi-disk backup array died. I didn't know, until I rebooted after system update. Fortunately, I had enough space to cover this failure. But, if another harddisk dies, then I will need to buy a new one.
What is your recommendation for NAS harddisk, nowadays? It's been awhile since I shopped for a harddisk. Google recommends Seagate Ironwolf Pro, but I got burned by Seagate before, and this one that died is also Seagate.
I saw an article recently that showed Seagate drives failed twice as often as WD drives. So it turns out it was not our imagination that Seagate drives were less reliable.
I run WD Red Plus drives.
I that that I also read that article. I believe it was based on the results of the Backblaze people. -- Alvin Starr || land: (647)478-6285 Netvel Inc. || home: (905)513-7688 alvin@netvel.net ||
On Tue, 22 Sep 2026 11:08:29 -0400 Lennart Sorensen via Talk <talk@lists.gtalug.org> wrote:
I saw an article recently that showed Seagate drives failed twice as often as WD drives. So it turns out it was not our imagination that Seagate drives were less reliable.
I run WD Red Plus drives.
A few years ago, I installed Fedora_26 unto a new, 2TB hard drive on my old motherboard. The install went okay, but it would not boot afterwards. "Loading Operating System ..." It turns out that installing a GPT formatted hard drive on an MBR only motherboard will cause problems. I went back and I got a new Seagate 2TB drive, and everything worked. The drive that would not boot was Western Digital. I could format, mount, and use the Western Digital drive, I just could not use it as a boot device. Basically, if you have new GPT capable drives and motherboards, or you have old MBR drives and motherboard, the install will go okay. A GPT drive and an MBR motherboard can make things interesting. In about thirty years, I think I have had one hard drive fail, and I don't recall the brand. My primary drive on my two latest computers are M.2 SSD drives. I love the speed. I do daily backups, so lifespan and reliability are not big concerns for me. -- Howard Gibson hgibson@eol.ca http://home.eol.ca/~hgibson
Interesting. It could've been an issue with the motherboard firmware. Because both WD and Seagate would have been formatted in MBR, since motherboard is MBR. On 2026-09-22 11:31, Howard Gibson via Talk wrote:
A few years ago, I installed Fedora_26 unto a new, 2TB hard drive on my old motherboard. The install went okay, but it would not boot afterwards. "Loading Operating System ..." It turns out that installing a GPT formatted hard drive on an MBR only motherboard will cause problems. I went back and I got a new Seagate 2TB drive, and everything worked. The drive that would not boot was Western Digital. I could format, mount, and use the Western Digital drive, I just could not use it as a boot device. Basically, if you have new GPT capable drives and motherboards, or you have old MBR drives and motherboard, the install will go okay. A GPT drive and an MBR motherboard can make things interesting.
In about thirty years, I think I have had one hard drive fail, and I don't recall the brand. My primary drive on my two latest computers are M.2 SSD drives. I love the speed. I do daily backups, so lifespan and reliability are not big concerns for me.
On Tue, Sep 22, 2026 at 11:31:20AM -0400, Howard Gibson via Talk wrote:
A few years ago, I installed Fedora_26 unto a new, 2TB hard drive on my old motherboard. The install went okay, but it would not boot afterwards. "Loading Operating System ..." It turns out that installing a GPT formatted hard drive on an MBR only motherboard will cause problems. I went back and I got a new Seagate 2TB drive, and everything worked. The drive that would not boot was Western Digital. I could format, mount, and use the Western Digital drive, I just could not use it as a boot device. Basically, if you have new GPT capable drives and motherboards, or you have old MBR drives and motherboard, the install will go okay. A GPT drive and an MBR motherboard can make things interesting.
In about thirty years, I think I have had one hard drive fail, and I don't recall the brand. My primary drive on my two latest computers are M.2 SSD drives. I love the speed. I do daily backups, so lifespan and reliability are not big concerns for me.
There were ways to have an MBR partition table along with GPT to allow MBR only systems to boot from GPT. I have done it. However, some WD drives around the start of 2TB+ were using 4KB sectors instead of 512B sectors, and that could cause issues for some BIOSes. -- Len Sorensen
The 16TB Seagate Ironwolf drive that has been holding the media in my home Ubuntu server died on Friday. Like with William, the problem didn't show up until a reboot with the startup fsck giving up after 5%. Further resuscitation attempts failed though `ddrescue` might still work. The drive only held media files and I had good onsite backups so disk recovery wasn't an issue. But then it came time to replace the drive. Hoo boy, the fun started. The old drive came with a three year warranty but had served well for at least a dozen years. And I realized that I didn't need 16TB going forward, 10TB would suit me fine. In researching a replacement (personal legwork assisted occasionally by two different GPT chatbots) I reached the personal conclusion that the new drive needed ro be from one of the three "Pro" lines out there optimized for NAS or media server use and have five-year warranties: - Seagate Ironwolf Pro - WD Red Pro - Toshiba N300 Pro All three are well rated with the Seagate slightly ahead. Now... go find a drive in *any* of those lines, in stock anywhere from Hamilton to Barrie to Pickering, for under $1,000. From any retailer; I tried Best Buy, Memory Express, NewEgg, even Amazon. Turns out Canada Computer lists a single 12TB Ironwolf Pro for $634 <https://www.canadacomputers.com/en/desktop-internal-hard-drives/238856/seagate-ironwolf-pro-12tb-hard-drive-3-5-internal-sata-sata-600-st12000nt001.html> . In stock at Mississauga. Or rather, they *had* one; it's mine now. (I see that they now have one at Richmond Hill and one in Barrie. That's changed since Friday. But you get the idea.) Arguing over Seagate vs WD vs Toshiba vs whatever may seem academic if you need a drive NOW and so little stock exists. Drives under 8TB and over 20TB appear in slightly better supply, but the former was insufficient and the latter was exorbitant. Even getting the 12TB was a little more than I needed, but 10TBs are in even shorter supply. Installation and recovery went fine. I'm now happy that I chose a case that was so easy to work with WRT drive replacement. William, I'll be interested to hear how your search for a replacement drive went. And I hope that the stock situation improves for everyone's sake. - Evan PS: I was really surprised at how *little* help the AI chatbots turned out to be, including the latest iteration,"Muse". Meta claims this thing can be your personal shopper, but it -- like all the others -- fell flat when making the leap from "find" to "acquire". It discovered multiple (out-of-stock) listings, but eventually left me to fend for myself to find where I could actually find one.
The drive that died was 3TB Seagate. So, I was looking for 4-8TB WD Red Pro. Canada Computers had sales on Seagate (may still do), but I didn't like the prices. I still had room to cover the loss, so I just re-balanced my array (BTRFS raid1). If another disk fails, then no choice. Question... you replaced 16TB with 12TB. What kind of filesystem do you use for your array? On 2026-09-28 14:13, Evan Leibovitch wrote:
The 16TB Seagate Ironwolf drive that has been holding the media in my home Ubuntu server died on Friday. Like with William, the problem didn't show up until a reboot with the startup fsck giving up after 5%. Further resuscitation attempts failed though `ddrescue` might still work.
The drive only held media files and I had good onsite backups so disk recovery wasn't an issue. But then it came time to replace the drive. Hoo boy, the fun started.
The old drive came with a three year warranty but had served well for at least a dozen years. And I realized that I didn't need 16TB going forward, 10TB would suit me fine. In researching a replacement (personal legwork assisted occasionally by two different GPT chatbots) I reached the personal conclusion that the new drive needed ro be from one of the three "Pro" lines out there optimized for NAS or media server use and have five-year warranties:
* Seagate Ironwolf Pro * WD Red Pro * Toshiba N300 Pro
All three are well rated with the Seagate slightly ahead.
Now... go find a drive in *any* of those lines, in stock anywhere from Hamilton to Barrie to Pickering, for under $1,000. From any retailer; I tried Best Buy, Memory Express, NewEgg, even Amazon.
Turns out Canada Computer lists a single 12TB Ironwolf Pro for $634 <https://www.canadacomputers.com/en/desktop-internal-hard-drives/238856/seagate-ironwolf-pro-12tb-hard-drive-3-5-internal-sata-sata-600-st12000nt001.html>. In stock at Mississauga. Or rather, they *had* one; it's mine now. (I see that they now have one at Richmond Hill and one in Barrie. That's changed since Friday. But you get the idea.)
Arguing over Seagate vs WD vs Toshiba vs whatever may seem academic if you need a drive NOW and so little stock exists. Drives under 8TB and over 20TB appear in slightly better supply, but the former was insufficient and the latter was exorbitant. Even getting the 12TB was a little more than I needed, but 10TBs are in even shorter supply.
Installation and recovery went fine. I'm now happy that I chose a case that was so easy to work with WRT drive replacement.
William, I'll be interested to hear how your search for a replacement drive went. And I hope that the stock situation improves for everyone's sake.
- Evan
PS: I was really surprised at how *little* help the AI chatbots turned out to be, including the latest iteration,"Muse". Meta claims this thing can be your personal shopper, but it -- like all the others -- fell flat when making the leap from "find" to "acquire". It discovered multiple (out-of-stock) listings, but eventually left me to fend for myself to find where I could actually find one.
On Mon, Sep 28, 2026 at 5:04 PM William Park via Talk <talk@lists.gtalug.org> wrote:
The drive that died was 3TB Seagate. So, I was looking for 4-8TB WD Red Pro. Canada Computers had sales on Seagate (may still do), but I didn't like the prices.
You're not going to like the prices for quite a while. A long conversation with the store clerk revealed that the stock and pricing situation isn't normalizing anytime soon. The consensus (corroborated elsewhere) appears that 2026 is a really crappy year to be building your own PC from fresh parts, and most people are best with a prebuilt or NUC-type all-in-one. Question... you replaced 16TB with 12TB. What kind of filesystem do you
use for your array?
Array? Nowhere near as sophisticated. It's just a single drive, ext4 (tuned for large files), with an offline backup. I've never used btrfs on my Ubuntu server, though it's what I'm using on my Cachy desktop. - Evan
participants (6)
-
Alvin Starr -
Evan Leibovitch -
Howard Gibson -
Lennart Sorensen -
tom.fran -
William Park