Interesting. It could've been an issue with the motherboard firmware. Because both WD and Seagate would have been formatted in MBR, since motherboard is MBR. On 2026-09-22 11:31, Howard Gibson via Talk wrote:
A few years ago, I installed Fedora_26 unto a new, 2TB hard drive on my old motherboard. The install went okay, but it would not boot afterwards. "Loading Operating System ..." It turns out that installing a GPT formatted hard drive on an MBR only motherboard will cause problems. I went back and I got a new Seagate 2TB drive, and everything worked. The drive that would not boot was Western Digital. I could format, mount, and use the Western Digital drive, I just could not use it as a boot device. Basically, if you have new GPT capable drives and motherboards, or you have old MBR drives and motherboard, the install will go okay. A GPT drive and an MBR motherboard can make things interesting.
In about thirty years, I think I have had one hard drive fail, and I don't recall the brand. My primary drive on my two latest computers are M.2 SSD drives. I love the speed. I do daily backups, so lifespan and reliability are not big concerns for me.