Fedora 44 and Wayland
I have just installed Fedora_44 onto my primary desktop. Fedora is replacing X11R6 with Wayland, and as of version_44, X11 is gone. The old highlight-middle-click copy and paste generally no longer works. When I install GNU/Linux, I make a point of installing the window managers XFCE, FVWM, LXDE nad Cinnamon. Except for XFCE, everything installed, but they are not visible at login time. I am switching from FVWM to Gnome. I hope that FVWM3 will work under Wayland someday. I have spent thirty years making FVWM do exactly what I want, so I miss it. I have a decent, fairly new computer here, so I have no speed issues. If X11R6 and its low CPU and memory window managers are gone, what do we do with old, slow computers? -- Howard Gibson hgibson@eol.ca http://home.eol.ca/~hgibson
From: Howard Gibson <hgibson@eol.ca>
I have just installed Fedora_44 onto my primary desktop. Fedora is replacing X11R6 with Wayland, and as of version_44, X11 is gone. The old highlight-middle-click copy and paste generally no longer works.
The GNOME-tweaks program, under "mouse & touchpad" lets you enable "Middle Click Paste". Alternatively, this command should work (under GNOME). gsettings set org.gnome.desktop.interface gtk-enable-primary-paste true There must be a way of doing that without GNOME but I don't know it.
When I install GNU/Linux, I make a point of installing the window managers XFCE, FVWM, LXDE nad Cinnamon. Except for XFCE, everything installed, but they are not visible at login time. I am switching from FVWM to Gnome.
The default "greeter" is GDM, part of gnome. It knows about some window managers. My guess is you installed, for example, XFCE with dnf environment install xfce-desktop-environment you'd get a better experience. To see all the available environments: dnf environment list I don't see FVWM but lxde and cinnamon are included. Note: I haven't tried installing extra Fedora desktop environments.
I hope that FVWM3 will work under Wayland someday. I have spent thirty years making FVWM do exactly what I want, so I miss it.
You might not be alone. Have you looked to see if others are working on this?
I have a decent, fairly new computer here, so I have no speed issues. If X11R6 and its low CPU and memory window managers are gone, what do we do with old, slow computers?
At some point, support is going away for old hardware. There are distros meant to run in low-resource environments.
From: D. Hugh Redelmeier <hugh@mimosa.com>
You might not be alone. Have you looked to see if others are working on this?
On Sun, 25 Oct 2026 15:30:20 -0400 (EDT) "D. Hugh Redelmeier" <hugh@mimosa.com> wrote:
My guess is you installed, for example, XFCE with dnf environment install xfce-desktop-environment you'd get a better experience.
To see all the available environments: dnf environment list I don't see FVWM but lxde and cinnamon are included.
Note: I haven't tried installing extra Fedora desktop environments.
I hope that FVWM3 will work under Wayland someday. I have spent thirty years making FVWM do exactly what I want, so I miss it.
You might not be alone. Have you looked to see if others are working on this?
Hugh, On Fedora_43, GDM shows all the window managers, and I can run whichever one I want. On Fedora_44, GDM shows only Gnome and Plasma. I am testing stuff here. I install and run the vector graphics program Xfig. This is working. I can launch xterms complete with all sorts of command line parameters, and the highlight-middle-click even works. -- Howard Gibson hgibson@eol.ca http://home.eol.ca/~hgibson
Howard Gibson said on Sun, 25 Oct 2026 13:22:08 -0400
I have just installed Fedora_44 onto my primary desktop. Fedora is replacing X11R6 with Wayland, and as of version_44, X11 is gone. The old highlight-middle-click copy and paste generally no longer works.
When I install GNU/Linux, I make a point of installing the window managers XFCE, FVWM, LXDE nad Cinnamon. Except for XFCE, everything installed, but they are not visible at login time. I am switching from FVWM to Gnome. I hope that FVWM3 will work under Wayland someday. I have spent thirty years making FVWM do exactly what I want, so I miss it.
I have a decent, fairly new computer here, so I have no speed issues. If X11R6 and its low CPU and memory window managers are gone, what do we do with old, slow computers?
Don't use Redhat choice-hostile distros? SteveT Steve Litt http://444domains.com
On Thu, 29 Oct 2026 19:09:55 -0400 Steve Litt <slitt@troubleshooters.com> wrote:
Don't use Redhat choice-hostile distros?
Steve, I have been running Fedora with all sorts of window managers, preferring FVWM. The problem is not Fedora and Red Hat as far as I can tell. It is Wayland. -- Howard Gibson hgibson@eol.ca http://home.eol.ca/~hgibson
On Thu, 2026/10/29 10:49:45PM -0400, Howard Gibson <hgibson@eol.ca> wrote: | I have been running Fedora with all sorts of window managers, | preferring FVWM. The problem is not Fedora and Red Hat as far as I can | tell. It is Wayland. I'm not familiar with current fedoras, but as a possibly useful data point, my desktop is running ubuntu 26 with Xorg and fvwm2, and seems to be happy. I have had Xorg wedge itself on occasion, but that may be related to my nvidia graphics card and Xorg's interaction with the drivers. Or it might not. I was afraid that the wayland default would doom me, but I just disabled the default graphical startup (as I alwayys have), and login and run startx. I'm a creature of (long term) habit. I haven't updated my laptop yet - I use the standard graphical interface on those, primarily because of the convenience of dynamic multiple displays, wifi network selection, and the like. Hope that's helpful. John
On Thu, Oct 29, 2026 at 11:50:04PM -0400, John Sellens wrote:
I'm not familiar with current fedoras, but as a possibly useful data point, my desktop is running ubuntu 26 with Xorg and fvwm2, and seems to be happy.
I have had Xorg wedge itself on occasion, but that may be related to my nvidia graphics card and Xorg's interaction with the drivers. Or it might not.
I was afraid that the wayland default would doom me, but I just disabled the default graphical startup (as I alwayys have), and login and run startx. I'm a creature of (long term) habit.
I haven't updated my laptop yet - I use the standard graphical interface on those, primarily because of the convenience of dynamic multiple displays, wifi network selection, and the like.
Hope that's helpful.
If you ever decide to move into what is apparently the future, there are projects like river and CoW that work on wayland but look and behave like fvwm. https://codeberg.org/cow-wm/cow https://codeberg.org/river/river Apparently porting fvwm to supporting wayland is essentially imposible because it is so fundamentally tied to how X11 works. -- Len Sorensen
On Fri, 2026/10/30 11:14:15AM -0400, Lennart Sorensen <lsorense@csclub.uwaterloo.ca> wrote: | If you ever decide to move into what is apparently the future, there | are projects like river and CoW that work on wayland but look and behave | like fvwm. | | https://codeberg.org/cow-wm/cow | https://codeberg.org/river/river | | Apparently porting fvwm to supporting wayland is essentially imposible | because it is so fundamentally tied to how X11 works. Thank you for the references! I had looked for something to replace fvwm within the past year, but had not yet found anything that looked promising. I don't necessarily relish trying to replicate my weird mouse button bindings in a different configuration language, but I've done it before. I'm stuck in a deep preference for keyboard focus follows mouse, and the ability to type into windows that are partially hidden by other windows, and being able to push windows to the back. And easily grab and resize windows *in the way I've always done it because I like my own choices!*. Habits can get deeply ingrained after a quarter century ... I'll have to wayland some day, I know, just hoping other cranky old geeks pave the way a little more smoothly first :-) Cheers John
On Thu, Oct 29, 2026 at 10:49:45PM -0400, Howard Gibson wrote:
On Thu, 29 Oct 2026 19:09:55 -0400 Steve Litt <slitt@troubleshooters.com> wrote:
Don't use Redhat choice-hostile distros?
Steve,
I have been running Fedora with all sorts of window managers, preferring FVWM. The problem is not Fedora and Red Hat as far as I can tell. It is Wayland.
If Fedora and Redhat decided wayland is mandatory, and wayland doesn't work for someone, then that would seem to make Fedora/Redhat the problem. -- Len Sorensen
From: Lennart Sorensen <lsorense@csclub.uwaterloo.ca>
If Fedora and Redhat decided wayland is mandatory, and wayland doesn't work for someone, then that would seem to make Fedora/Redhat the problem.
No, the real problem is that the X developers have declared the project dead. With reason. The code base that we use (XFree 386?) and the X standard are dead. Someone could continue it, but anyone that does this would need to earn a reputation very quickly for me to care. If you go to <https://www.x.org/> nothing hints at this status. But look at the date of the last annual report: 2017.
D. Hugh Redelmeier said on Fri, 30 Oct 2026 11:27:42 -0400 (EDT)
From: Lennart Sorensen <lsorense@csclub.uwaterloo.ca>
If Fedora and Redhat decided wayland is mandatory, and wayland doesn't work for someone, then that would seem to make Fedora/Redhat the problem.
No, the real problem is that the X developers have declared the project dead. With reason. The code base that we use (XFree 386?) and the X standard are dead.
Fetchmail is dead, not maintained for years. I choose to use it every 3 minutes to move my email from my ISP to my personal Dovecot server, and my distro doesn't remove the fetchmail package just because it's dead. This isn't about the relevant merits of X vs Wayland. It's about choice, and various distros' attitude toward choice. SteveT Steve Litt http://444domains.com
Howard Gibson said on Thu, 29 Oct 2026 22:49:45 -0400
On Thu, 29 Oct 2026 19:09:55 -0400 Steve Litt <slitt@troubleshooters.com> wrote:
Don't use Redhat choice-hostile distros?
Steve,
I have been running Fedora with all sorts of window managers, preferring FVWM. The problem is not Fedora and Red Hat as far as I can tell. It is Wayland.
We're saying the same thing. Redhat disallows you running Xorg. They also disallow non-systemd inits, and back when I tested CentOS in 2014, it wouldn't even allow things like the FVWM you're running (or in my case, Openbox). Devuan assists you in running any of four init systems, and doesn't stand in your way with any others. You can run X or Wayland, with lots of different WMs, DEs and compositors. Since the departure of Robert Young, Redhat is in it for the money, and nothing else. Monopolism and removal of choice are the modern route to money. There are zillions of distros outside the Redhat ecosystem, and many don't force you into Wayland. SteveT Steve Litt http://444domains.com
From: Steve Litt <slitt@troubleshooters.com>
We're saying the same thing. Redhat disallows you running Xorg. They also disallow non-systemd inits, and back when I tested CentOS in 2014, it wouldn't even allow things like the FVWM you're running (or in my case, Openbox).
Not accurate. They don't enable you to use these things but if you put in the work you can run them. It's open source! If you want to share the effort, you could submit things to a third-party repository. My guess is that adding X would require extensive changes, but maybe most of that is hidden inside a few libraries. It should be easy to add a daemon to run an additional init system. The old System V system coexisted with SystemD for a long time. Personally, I'm glad to be rid of it. It's painful to delete features, even obsolete ones. I'm glad that Fedora / Red Hat is doing a bit of that work. Nobody is doing enough. I am too old to start over, and have been for a long time, or I might have adopted Plan 9. From a subsequent message:
Fetchmail is dead, not maintained for years. I choose to use it every 3 minutes to move my email from my ISP to my personal Dovecot server, and my distro doesn't remove the fetchmail package just because it's dead.
I would like a maintainer for software I use. I don't want to use abandoned code, particularly in these times where everything gets attacked. Fedora responds to security problems discovered in any packages they distribute. Having said that: - a new team is maintaining fetchmail <https://www.fetchmail.info/> - fetchmail is still in Fedora - fetchmail's RPM has RedHat changelog entries. On 2025 December 2025 they updated the package to fetchmail-6.6.2 to resolve bug reports. (Upstream has 6.6.9; several bug fixes are missing in 6.6.2. I'm too lazy to submit a report.) - some drama is hinted at in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fetchmail - one person in my household uses fetchmail on occasion - there are replacements: getmail6, maybe FDM, maybe IdleMail (getmail itself is still in Python 2!)
On Sun, Oct 25, 2026 at 01:22:08PM -0400, Howard Gibson wrote:
I have just installed Fedora_44 onto my primary desktop. Fedora is replacing X11R6 with Wayland, and as of version_44, X11 is gone. The old highlight-middle-click copy and paste generally no longer works.
I think there are two issues people are confusing here: 1. GNOME 50 droped the X11 backend, and is wayland only. Therefore: 2. Fedora Workstation, which uses GNOME and is the primary desktop target for Fedora, doesn't ship X11 by default (it still includes XWayland). This doesn't mean Fedora stopped packaging an X server. There are official Fedora spins that don't have a stable/complete Wayland backend (XFCE being the main one, but I think a fair number of them are X11-only still). You can install the X server on Workstation. GNOME can't use it still, but it will be there. If you install an X11 Window Manager, it will use that X server backend. FWIW, Fedora also doesn't ship vi by default, which is far more egregious. You can install it, though.
When I install GNU/Linux, I make a point of installing the window managers XFCE, FVWM, LXDE nad Cinnamon. Except for XFCE, everything installed, but they are not visible at login time.
I did not have xorg-x11-server-Xorg (or any of the xorg-x11-drv-* packages) installed. I installed xfce (via @xfce-desktop-environment), blackbox, and fvwm. All three show up in gdm, and gdm can still initialize Xorg sessions for them. I've logged into all three from gdm. Works fine. (You also don't have to use gdm if you want to avoid Wayland entirely) Note: I saw discussion that it may be better to reboot (vs restarting gdm) to have the X11 sessions appear. There may be systemd and/or selinux and/or something else that runs at boot, which wasn't done (because it wasn't installed at boot). This didn't *seem* to be the case on my system (they appeared when restarting GDM), but I rebooted before testing them, as I didn't want to potentially add extra troubleshooting into a quick test. I'm on Fedora 45.
I have a decent, fairly new computer here, so I have no speed issues. If X11R6 and its low CPU and memory window managers are gone, what do we do with old, slow computers?
Probably still run XFCE/LXQT/whatever with X11 on those, with whatever you were using before. It's not like modern GNOME was light on resources when it was using X11, so you probably were not using that on resource-constrained systems. Depending on how old/slow the systems in question are, I suspect you're going to soon have other issues running "modern" distros on them: - Many distros dropped support for 32-bit systems. Even Debian doesn't provide a 32-bit install image anymore. - A number of distros are considering newer CPU instruction set revisions (ex: x86-64-v3). Some are doing this in parallel (Fedora), while others will draw a hard-line to break support with older systems (Red Hat). - The kernel is starting to drop older hardware drivers now, while previously they'd just "live-on" in a quasi-unsupported state. There will probably be more distros like Shork-486 to keep older hardware running. I expect this will be more as a niche interest, rather than something you want to put on the Internet. -- Chris Irwin email: chris@chrisirwin.ca web: https://chrisirwin.ca
participants (6)
-
Chris Irwin -
D. Hugh Redelmeier -
Howard Gibson -
John Sellens -
Lennart Sorensen -
Steve Litt