On 2026-11-08 22:28, Steve Petrie wrote:
Actually my *aspetrie.net* email is handled by *siteground.com*
Perhaps siteground.com outsources it to mailspamprotection.com but they aren't hosting it themselves. They handle the billing I guess.
I know that the 3 DNS MX records say: *mailspamprotection.com*
And that's the proof of who is running the email servers.
I assume *mailspamprotection.com* may be part of the SiteGround infrastructure.
Possibly.
*For sure SiteGround does support DKIM.*
No, they do not have MX records.
I know this because today i was getting DKIM help from the SiteGround website AI assistant.
AI bots can be remarkable, but also utterly wrong. siteground.com does not run (public) email servers: $ resolvectl query --type mx siteground.com siteground.com IN MX 30 mx30.antispam.mailspamprotection.com siteground.com IN MX 10 mx10.antispam.mailspamprotection.com siteground.com IN MX 20 mx20.antispam.mailspamprotection.com
For example: If you’re sending emails for this domain name [aspetrie.net] through our servers and wish to use DKIM, add the DKIM record below to your DNS zone. Recommended DKIM record default._domainkey 14400 IN TXT "v=DKIM1;k=rsa;p=MIGfMA0GCSqGSIb3DQEBAQUAA4GNADCBiQKBgQC1wFCxwgkNxk2xTpa3iXkMzoP3eFrJOTaVy1SBJccl/TSpxYmWf1dto0ALg5CQo2fAbQWmC0gOaS3kmrS0q+elMD31UeNvoRvZ50Uf3yXy4gjDh7gb5QFLM0KfUFK4qs53g1bucUmzyRdBzHEFU/6Ds12v9GMT8UC7dF/V1dHGEQIDAQAB"
That appears to be a good DKIM record, except that it's not attached to any MX server because aspetrie.net does not run any MX servers.
However, when I created the DNS TXT DKIM record, Namecheap stripped the leading and trailing double quote characters from the string: "v=DKIM1;k=rsa;p=MIGfM ... V1dHGEQIDAQAB"
I do see a TXT record for aspetrie.net, which contains the text "default._domainkey" and two double quoted strings. However, default._domainkey.aspetrie.net should be the NAME of the entry, like www.aspetrie.net, but the type would be TXT, where www would be type A (and / or AAAA).
*Wonder if the missing double quotes are a problem ??*
I'm looking at one of my DKIM records, it has 2 quoted strings in it. The GTALUG one (below) has only one. Check a valid record by running this: resolvectl query --type txt default._domainkey.lists.gtalug.org
I am adding the DNS DKIM record because it seems that Microsoft tightened its email server requirements for handling incoming emails. And I have some contacts who use MS-provided email addresses. Once I get the DKIM record working, I will also need to create a DMARC record too.
That won't work. Change providers, the current ones are not competent if they don't have DKIM yet. Hopefully someone will point out a flaw in my knowledge. Also, I do run email hosting which does not suffer deliverability issues that I'm aware of should you be interested. SMTP, POP3, IMAP. Sadly, no JMAP.